What No One Ever Told You About Behavior Management
Monday, September 10th, 2007A significant portion of my professional career has been devoted to behavior analysis and modification plans. Initially, though still considerable, my success rate was not as high as it currently is.
There was one reason why.I failed to take into account the underlying temperaments of the subjects and clients.
This adjustment has improved my effectiveness in public education, corrections counseling and private counseling to an enormous, even immeasurable degree.
Although, it is impossible to put the entirety of my findings here, I have managed to distill a few of the major tenets.
1. Most behavior is learned.Whether by design, or by chance, an exhibited behavior has yielded a desirable result at some time. Consider your arrival home from the market. You are greeted by your cat, which comes to investigate your recent purchases. While you set about opening the can of tuna for the kitty, she entwines herself about your ankles and in the process bumps her head three times against the cabinet. Coincidentally, at this exact moment you place the food in her dish. “Tah-Dah!” You have just witnessed the birth of a “learned behavior.’
Now, every time you prepare to feed the cat, she bumps her head three times on the cabinet. In her mind the two are connected as cause and effect.
Of course this is an extreme over simplification, but you may draw your own parallels to human behavior.
2. Systematically repeating an action until you automatically perform the action without consciously thinking about it is the working definition for a habit. This holds true for positive behaviors such as brushing your teeth after meals as well as negative behaviors such as having a smoke after dinner (see for example the classroom procedures of Harry K. Wong and the 7 Habits of Highly Effective People).
3. Once a habit is established, it takes at least 2 to 4 weeks of consciously substituting a positive replacement behavior before the bad habit is considered to be “broken.
4. Behavior can be adapted; personality can adjust to the environment; but underlying temperament can not be changed.
Keep these truths in mind when thinking about behavior management. Practically applied this means, placing a choleric temperament in a subservient role will always result in discord and displays of maladaptive behaviors.
5. Temperament, or ones core “self” is not determined by gender, age, ethnicity or economic status. Attempting to modify a maladaptive behavior without taking into account the underlying temperament will only lead to frustration on the part of the individual attempting to change the maladaptive behavior. This is true whether the individual is attempting to change their own behavior or another individual is attempting to modify the behavior of a subject or client. This is one instance in which the adage, “fake it until you make it,” simply does not apply.
6. Although we often use the terms interchangeably Behavior Management is NOT the same as Behavior Analysis. Behavior Analysis is a science concerned with what people do and say. Behavior analysis focuses on the voluntary and physiological influences on behavior. Behavior Management focuses on the motivation for and results of specific behaviors.
7. Your may have noticed that most behaviors are accompanied by one of six primary emotions (Parrot, 2001). Those primary emotions are: a) Love b) Joy c) Surprise d) Anger e) Sadness and f) Fear.
If you are adept at understanding these six emotions, you will have useful insight into the accompanying behaviors.
8. The study of behavior and emotion is not a new field. Aristotle compiled a list of core emotions ages ago. The items in the list of Aristotle are: a) Anger b)Mildness c)Love d) Enmity e) Fear f) Confidence g) Shame h) Shamelessness i) Benevolence j) Pity k) Indignation l) Envy m)Emulation and n) Contempt.
9. The study of behavior without the study of underlying temperament is an exercise in futility. The list of temperaments is: a) Choleric b) Melancholy c) Supine d) Phlegmatic and e) Sanguine.
10. You cannot force changes in behavior. I should say, permanent changes to behavior probably cannot be forced. The gun to the head theory only holds true for as long as you hold the gun to the head. Once you remove the threat of harm (or negative stimulus), the behavior most likely will return.
In real estate and business, the elemental truth is simple “Location, Location, and Location.”
In behavior management, the elemental truth is similar, “documentation, documentation, and documentation.”
A friend of mine, (Bert Webb) who publishes Open Loops, a site on efficiency and effectiveness in education and business, and I have worked together on several projects designed to streamline documentation. Most of these have taken the form of fill in the blank and pop up electronic documents that greatly increase the speed with which we may record the information.
You may contact me for samples, if you wish.
11. Write out, in detail, the specific behavior that you see as the problem. Let it “cool” for 24 hours and read what you wrote. If you still consider the behavior to be a problem you should continue to the next step.
Keep in mind, temporary inconveniences, or things that will not affect your efficiency, effectiveness or growth really are not problems. In these instances, you should use what I like to call “Lincoln’s Logic.”
If Abraham Lincoln had a problem with someone’s behavior, he sat down and wrote a letter that illuminated that person’s shortcomings in great and cruel detail. He then, having gotten it off his chest, put it in a drawer to cool. If, when he read the letter 24 hours later, he still felt it was important enough to address he would take the issue up with the person.
12. In your documentation, you must be sure you are addressing the problem behavior and not the person. For example, you would not say, “Mr. Edwards is always late.” Instead, you would record, “On the dates of 4/1, 4/2, 4/3 and 4/5 Mr. Edwards arrived at 9:15. Arrival time is 9:00.”
13. Although, you may assume the person is aware there is a problem that may not be the case. At this point, you should explain your expectations to the person. In many cases making the person aware there is a problem solves the problem. Make sure you record this exchange with dates and times.
14. If the area continues to be a problem, you should develop a plan of action. Explain in detail what you expect the person to do to correct the situation.
At this point, if you are in the business community, you may be asking “why?”
The answer is money.
It is almost invariably less expensive to “grow a great employee” from what you have than it is to recruit, hire and train a new one.
If you are in education, similar elemental truths hold true. It is “better” to “grow a great student” from what you have, than it is to be miserably unhappy with what you have.
15. You must come to agreement on the plan to replace the maladaptive behavior. If both parties do not buy in to the solution, it is unlikely to be successful. Document this agreement with signatures and dates on a written plan of action.
16. There are no instant fixes. No matter what Dr. H.’Andin Urpocket tells you, there is nothing you can do that will immediately cure maladaptive behavior.
You may trust me on this one. If there were a “fix” for all behavior problems, I would have found it by now. Then I would have written a book about it and sold it on Oprah.
Anyone who tells you they have the solution to every behavior problem is telling you a lie. Nothing works in every case. Some people respond to affection. Some people respond to reason. Some people respond to inspiration. No one person has THE key to EVERYONE’S maladaptive behavior.
I have been in this field for many years. If there is one thing I have learned, it is every type of lock has a different type of key.
17. The more information you have about a person, the greatly the likelihood you will be able to influence their behavior.
Furthermore, the broader the range of information, the better it is for you. In the business community it is not only important to know how well the person “does their job.” It is also important to know how the person functions outside the work environment.
The same is true for the education field. The more data you have about your student, the greater the likelihood you will be able to effectively influence their behavior.
18. Although process and innovation driven intervention techniques are not mutually exclusive, it may be more prudent to utilize process models.
I say this for a simple reason. It is easier to justify actions taken based on the process model than it is to justify those from the innovation model.
19. You are not the first person who has had to deal with behavior management. Read everything you can find on the subject. Pick out the parts you like. Compile those parts you like into a standard strategies pack and use them.
The amount of work that has been done on motivation, responsibility, impulsivity and respect boggles the mind. Go “Google” motivation and you will get about 154,000,000 hits. The likelihood that you or I will come up with something completely new is marginal.
20. Don’t obsess. Once you have taken corrective action, give your action time to have an impact. If you do not follow this tip, the problem will no longer be about someone else. It will be about you. For years, I have taught the following guideline. “Q-TIP”
Q = quit
T = taking
I = it
P = personally
During the first twenty of these items, I have tried to offer you some of the best strategies and thinking for behavior management. For the final phase, I will list and discuss some of the most common mistakes.
21. Ineffective praise is one of the most common mistakes made in behavior management. While it is true, specific, enthusiastic praise can be a powerful tool; improper use may not only be ineffective but I consider it condescending, as well.
22. Introduction of too much fee time is another mistake. Often, we build free time into a system as a reward for productivity. Now take a moment to think about that, “free time as a reward for productivity.” Do I need to expound upon the tragedy of that logic?
The rule of thumb is if you are busy, you do not have time for problem behaviors.
23. Sarcasm is one of the most detrimental elements that you can introduce. Even if you are adept at sarcasm and all of your remarks border on the hilarious, it is a bad idea. When people are stung by sarcasm, they spend the remainder of their time sulking, or plotting their revenge in the next event allowing the exchange or witty repartee. Very little positive work gets accomplished.
24. Inconsistency can cause you monumental problems. If you plan to correct a behavior, make sure you have the energy to address it every single time. If you do not, you are better off ignoring the thing entirely.
25. You must avoid power struggles at all costs. If it is necessary for you to give a command do so. Remember to speak clearly and slowly, use a gentle touch, and make good eye contact. Then reinforce the compliance with a thank you.
None of these strategies will be productive in isolation. Absorb them all and chose the tools that fit your particular need and circumstance.








